©️ The contents of this website are copyrighted to Paul Stichbury 2013 – 2024. All rights reserved
Update 22 April 2024
Submissions on the Fast Track Approvals Bill have closed. Here is my submission.
Update 21 March 2024
The Government wants to tear up the Resource Management Act. Many sectors are aware that poor decisions and corruption will follow. If you are concerned then you need to make a submission. Full details at the link below.
“Luxon said New Zealand had become an “obstruction economy”, held back by red tape in its efforts to upgrade infrastructure. He cited the years it takes to consent wind farms which will help the country achieve its climate change targets.
Some of the projects will be good for the environment given they would lower emissions, Bishop argued. He cited how energy companies believed the Resource Management Act was a massive stumbling block for projects such as wind farms.”
The Turitea Reserve and the former Motorimu wind farm, consented and not built are sure to be targets.
Check out what your neighbours face.
NEW Discussion on matters covered on this site https://substack.com/@paulstichbury
Update 5 February 2024
Note: Mercury Insurance Captive Ltd merged with WHAT POWER CRISIS (2016) LIMITED 28 Oct 2022
This further obscures the apparent lack of full insurance raised on this site. See below.
Update 30 January 2024
This website continues to get a lot of traffic – the web counter does not record visits from VPN users but the documents downloaded show in the daily stats. In the past 14 days or so this document has been downloaded 85 times.
It gives a good background introduction which is brought up to date with the submission to the Australian Senate Inquiry which is also a download favourite.
Kenderdine’s massive fraud goes way beyond the “naughty” appropriation of the title of a warranted “judge”
https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1981/0113/latest/DLM53562.html
$465 million was siphoned from Green Bond purchasers to build the Turitea wind farm on the Wellington and Northern Ohariu faults. These investors assumed the consent was legal but foolishly did not do any due diligence. If they had they would have run a mile. The Financial Markets Authority was told well in advance of the 49% of Mercury being sold off to unsuspecting investors that the consent was fraudulent and the wind farm is on major faults subject to a massive 9 on the Richter Scale. The FMA itself should be the subject of a Commission of Inquiry and heads should roll. Green bond owners stand to lose everything.
“The Financial Markets Authority – Te Mana Tātai Hokohoko – regulates New Zealand’s financial markets. We stand for a strong and trusted financial sector that treats people fairly.”
Of course, you could lodge a complaint of fraud. You might even get the case number “2345” as I did.
Update 7 November 2023
After this winter’s close shaves, Transpower warns of more concerns ahead due to the unreliability of wind power.
The Turitea Board of Inquiry was told this – however, no attention was paid by the messianic, delusional, criminal, Ms Kenderdine busy playing God while banking her bribes.
Update 1 November 2023
The Financial Markets Authority submitted to the Government’s secret directive to hide vital information from investors. Here is their reply to me written six weeks before we discovered Kenderdine was a fake judge and the consent she issued was a fraud. Investigators sifting through the mountain of evidence on this website have discovered this correspondence.
Update 18 October 2023
You too can be a judge. The Department of Justice has vacancies and is advertising them on LinkedIn.
The great thing about being a judge or not being one and masquerading as one is that you will get away with it when it suits the Government’s purpose. Welcome to the third world! Oh, and the pay is extra good.
https://www.justice.govt.nz/about/statutory-vacancies/
Appointment as a District Court or Environment Court
If you wish to register your interest in appointment as a District or Environment Court Judge you can fill in this form:
Expression of interest form [PDF, 116 KB]
or you can read more about it in this booklet:
Judicial appointments information booklet [PDF, 360 KB]
Update 12 September 2023
Environment Court Reports are additional proof supporting the Gascoigne confession that Kenderdine faked being a judge for 13 months. She committed this crime as a private citizen and affected property owners would have an ironclad case to sue her for damages. The registrar reports only list warranted judges and Commissioners. Kenderdine does not appear in the 2011 report. Judicial immunity does not apply.
EC_Registrars_Report_2010 kenderdine
EC_Registrar_Report_2011 Kenderdine
The Financial Markets Authority was contacted and knew the consent was fake and that the wind farm was approved on very dangerous faults. These letters were sent to the FMA also pointing out that James Millar was on the FMA and Mighty River Power boards – a serious conflict of interest.
Update 9 September 2023
The purchasers of unsecured, unsubordinated fixed rate green bonds were not told that their money, spent on Turitea, was for a wind farm which does not have a legal consent and that the fake “consent” was issued by Kenderdine, impersonating a judge for 13 months. The purchasers were also not told that the wind farm is right on the Wellington and Northern Ohariu fault lines. This is blatant fraud.
https://www.mercury.co.nz/investors/bonds/green-bonds/mcy040-bonds
There is no evidence that the wind farm is fully insured.
Update 16 August 2023
Bryan Leyland exposes the renewable energy fraud.
Copy and paste this link in your browser or right-click and open in a new tab.
Update 5 August 2023
You can check the property for sale under the wind farm here. There’s no interest. Many submitters told the Board of Inquiry that their greatest asset was at risk but Kenderdine and her merry gang of thieves ignored them. To the many recent visitors to this website probably the best course of action is to demand a commission of Inquiry. It’s election year, make your voices heard.
Copy and paste this link in your browser or right-click and open in a new tab.
Update 14 May 2023
Hundreds of submissions against the wind farm were factual, eloquent, and carefully written. This one showed the author realised exactly what was going on.
https://turiteadocuments.files.wordpress.com/2017/12/632coadj.pdf
Update 8 May 2023
This link takes you to all the first submissions. It is easier to open them than on the Home Page. Many have searched for their submissions.
The danger from the enormous area of shallow, locked plate boundary in the lower half of the North Island has been known for years. This startling evidence has just been published for all to see. The NZ Government has been reckless in the extreme by putting wind farms on fault lines in this high seismic risk zone. First Turitea and next Puketoi. It has in the guise of Mercury corruptly got green bond purchasers to fund this train wreck. Mercury now owns almost all of the turbines up to the Gorge.
Note, in this article the writer has missed a vital point in that the Wellington fault not only moves violently metres vertically but, horizontally as well.
A horizontal displacement up to 17 metres in 1855 was recently discovered .
Update 7 May 2023
May 1 was our busiest day ever with 4,520 downloads. The criminals who forced the wind farm on the city have nowhere to hide.
Update 6 May 2023
To avoid having to confront public protests that the wind farm does not have a consent and is on two of the country’s most dangerous faultlines, Woods held a private opening ceremony. Fraudster and fake judge Shonagh Kenderdine was nowhere in sight, likely in her counting house counting out her money.
The local Iwi who sold their maunga [mountains] to the government for reportedly $3 million dollars indicate their intention to extort more at some future time.
“[Danielle Harris] said Rangitāne had benefitted from being part of a project to generate energy for the region, and that contributed to economic growth and wellbeing.
The completion of works on site would be followed by a planting of some 31,000 plants to help restore and enhance the site.
But she said the landscape had changed forever.
“There will be a time when Māori will say enough is enough of windmills on our maunga.”
https://www.stuff.co.nz/manawatu-standard/news/131946699/turitea-wind-farm-emerges-from-the-mist
Local Maori are obviously uncomfortable at being used as props for a hastily arranged covert opening ceremony.
Update 29 March 2023
ChatGPT the artificial intelligence platform sweeping the world is expected to result in 300 million Europeans and North Americans losing their jobs.
“One-fourth of current work tasks could be automated by AI in the US and Europe.”
Here is the almost instantaneous, unbiased, non-partisan, commonsense ChatGPT, response to this simple question.
Is it a good idea to build a wind farm on a major fault line that generates level 8 earthquakes on the Richter scale?
No, it is not a good idea to build a wind farm on a major fault line that generates level 8 earthquakes on the Richter scale.
Earthquakes are a natural phenomenon that can cause significant damage to infrastructure and pose a significant risk to human life. Building a wind farm on a major fault line would increase the risk of damage to the wind turbines and other infrastructure, as well as the risk of injury or death to workers and nearby residents.
In addition, wind turbines are designed to withstand a certain level of wind speed and vibration, but they may not be able to withstand the intense shaking and ground movement caused by an earthquake of that magnitude. This could result in significant damage to the wind turbines and the entire wind farm, leading to costly repairs and downtime.
Furthermore, building a wind farm on a major fault line could also have negative environmental impacts. The construction of the wind turbines and associated infrastructure could disrupt local ecosystems and habitats, and the operation of the wind farm could generate noise pollution and other disturbances.
Overall, building a wind farm on a major fault line that generates level 8 earthquakes on the Richter scale is not a good idea due to the significant risks and potential negative impacts. It is important to carefully consider the location and potential risks of any infrastructure project to ensure the safety of workers and nearby residents, as well as the protection of the environment.
ChatGPT demonstrates we are ruled by disposable morons and criminals.
Update 21 March 2023
*This website is being hammered by what are clearly lawyers judging by the important documents being downloaded multiple times. Recently there have been up to 407 individual downloads on a single day. 88 yesterday.
*S&P Global know they have been defrauded.
*Vestas by now will know that they have been swept up in a fraud. This will hurt their brand.
*Nick Smith who forced the Call-In is erecting the turbines. He is intimately involved in the fraud.
*No legal sanctions have been imposed on us nor can they be. We are telling the truth!
*The New Zealand Government has by flouting its own laws and sanctioning corruption, destroyed its international reputation and made a mockery of the separation of powers and the independence of the judicial system. The Government has set the standard. No one needs to obey the Resource Management Act.
Update 20 March 2023
The Government is trying to hide concerns that retired NZ judges like Kenderdine are easy targets for corruption.
The archived source for this important document is available here.
Note where the link to this evidence went.
http://ip29.publications.lawcom.govt.nz/chapter+3+-+judicial+appointments/acting+judges
Update 17 March 2023
This document is proving to be very popular. The criminals can’t claim ignorance.
The number of hits and downloads is many thousands more than the site meter shows as people are using VPNs.
Update 10 March 2023
This image shows the obvious, tectonic vulnerability the Puketoi wind farm faces. There has been a massive amount of new data exposing the very serious threat of earthquake damage to the lower half of the North Island. Alarm bells are ringing. Contact GNS science for the latest as the survey of the Hikurangi trench has revealed potentially thousands of scenarios which were previously unknown. There were only 10 scenarios identified in 2010.
Updated 6 March 2023
Local authorities all know about the earthquake risk but they are not telling you that the expected quake on the Wellington fault right under the wind farm will be an 8.
Updated 7 February 2023
It is very unfortunate that the terrible earthquake in Turkey closely resembles the Wellington Fault in likely magnitude, depth, a strike slip event and very close to the city. The fraudulent Turitea wind farm is literally being built on an epicentre. Local residents please prepare for such an event as best you can. EQC can give advice. PNCC’s own data, revealed here, indicates a similar event is likely.
According to USGS seismologist Susan Hough, the quake risked being particularly dangerous due to its location and shallow depth.
“The world has seen bigger magnitudes than this over the past 10-20 years,” she tweeted. “but quakes close to M8 are not common on shallow strike-slip fault systems, and by virtue of proximity to population centers can be especially deadly.”
https://www.zerohedge.com/energy/devastating-footage-emerges-after-78-magnitude-earthquake-turkey
Updated 29 January 2023
Submission made to the Inquiry into ASIC conduct
Updated 21 January 2023
The Australian Government is holding an Inquiry.
That the following matter be referred to the Economics References Committee for inquiry and report by the last sitting day in June 2024.
The capacity and capability of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission to undertake proportionate investigation and enforcement action arising from reports of alleged misconduct, with particular reference to:
a. the potential for dispute resolution and compensation schemes to distort efficient market outcomes and regulatory action;
b. the balance in policy settings that deliver an efficient market but also effectively deter poor behaviour;
c. whether ASIC is meeting the expectations of government, business and the community with respect to regulatory action and enforcement;
d. the range and use of various regulatory tools and their effectiveness in contributing to good market outcomes;
e. the offences from which penalties can be considered and the nature of liability in these offences;
f. the resourcing allocated to ensure investigations and enforcement action progresses in a timely manner;
g. opportunities to reduce duplicative regulation; and
h. any other related matters.
Complaint sent to the ASX – Australian Stock Exchange
Updated 11 December 2022
The very comprehensive Report of the Manawatu-Wanganui Regional Lifelines Project in January 2005 warning that Palmerston North will be affected by an earthquake of magnitude 8 at least once every 150 years has been discovered on an archive.
The frequency of a magnitude 8 on the Wellington fault affecting Palmerston North is more than twice that of the Alpine Fault which produces an 8 approximately every 300 years. Why has this been hidden from the public? The Hikurangi trench off the East Coast can produce a 9. The probability is 25% over the next 50 years. It’s way past time there is a focus on the lower half of the North Island and infrastructure including uninsurable wind farms.
http://www.nzlifelines.org.nz/
NOTE No documents relating to hazards affecting infrastructure mention wind farms, but cover infrastructure such as roads, bridges, railways. Is this a deliberate oversight? It certainly looks like it.
NOTE
The Napier earthquake 3 February 1931
When the earthquake, measuring 7.8 on the Richter scale, struck at 10.47 a.m., many buildings in central Napier and Hastings collapsed. In terms of loss of life (at least 256), it remains the worst civil disaster to have occurred in New Zealand.
An 8 earthquake on the Richter Scale is 0.2 bigger than a 7.8
But almost twice as strong
https://earthquake.usgs.gov/education/calculator.php
https://www.horizons.govt.nz/flood-emergency-management/regional-hazards
John Love outed
“The investing public is protected by a raft of legislation from fraud. Are you are making a pitch to the naive and gullible for your own financial gain?”
Updated 7 December 2022
Palmerston North City Council knew in 2005 that there is a regular severe earthquake risk to the city but still went ahead and partnered with the government to build a wind farm right on the Wellington and Northern Ohariu faults.
This document – see quotes below – was authored by PNCC and subsequently deleted with other incriminating documents from the internet archive and its own website.
Quote One
Seismic Hazards
There are scattered earthquake sources that have been identified throughout the Manawatu region and beyond.
[1]
The Wellington and Wairarapa fault systems are major earthquake sources, and the Wellington system in particular can seriously affect Palmerston North. The Report of the Manawatu-Wanganui Regional Lifelines Project in January 2005 indicates that there is a strong probability that Palmerston North will be affected by an earthquake of magnitude 8 at least once every 150 years.
NOTE
An 8 magnitude earthquake will see the destruction of the High Turitea dam and very likely the Lower dam with up to 127 lives lost [PNCC’s Water engineer Dora Luo’s findings, through Tonkin and Taylor https://www.tonkintaylor.co.nz/%5D. The wind farm will be knocked flat. Palmerston North has been settled since the 1860’s – circa 160 years ago. The city is likely due for an 8 on the Richter Scale at any time.
Quote Two
Policy principles
The Council has agreed on the following principles, which underlie all its policies. These are:
Sustainability: The Council takes into account the long-term social, economic, environmental and cultural well being of communities, now and for the
future.
Participation: The Council supports and encourages opportunities for individuals and groups to actively participate in community life.
Accessibility: The Council is committed to removing barriers that prevent individuals and groups from accessing any aspect of community life.
Diversity: The Council respects the diversity of Palmerston North communities and the differing needs of groups within these communities.
Partnership: The Council acknowledges the benefits of developing relationships with others in the community, and will work in partnership to
progress our common goals.
Effectiveness: The Council will allocate resources so that they are directed to where they are most needed.
NOTE
The Council tore up its obligations and policy principles mandated under the 2002 Local Government Act by secretly signing the MRP Contract and Variation
The purpose of local government is—
(a) to enable democratic local decision-making and action by, and on behalf of, communities; and
(b) to promote the social, economic, environmental, and cultural well-being of communities in the present and for the future.
https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2002/0084/latest/DLM171803.html
Updated 22 November 2022.
Karen Price DELETED her law firm’s Capability Statement but of course, it is saved here just as this entire website has been saved repeatedly on the internet archive. Visitors to this website have been looking for it.
Click to access capability_statement2013.pdf
Should you come across a 404 on this website go here
Updated 24 September 2022
Here is the latest on the Hikurangi subduction zone. Over a million views in just 5 months. The risk to the wind farm is extreme. Don’t take our word for it watch and learn. That idiot fake judge Ms Kenderdine claimed in the Final Decision that “fault rupture is not expected to be an issue.”
Updated 11 August 2022
This massive gully was dug unseen through the site without input by submitters. PNCC has bent over for the wind farm cabal and, as you can see from the screenshots from the document linked below, the danger to the city’s water supply is rated as a HIGH RISK.
Submitters will be appalled at how city planners have cavalierly endangered the city’s water supply by adding additional risk to the potential massive earthquake risk which could according to GNS Science be as strong as 9 on the Richter Scale knocking out the wind farm, Turitea dams, associated infrastructure with a death toll in the Turitea valley as high as 127. [PNCC’s own data]
These works required approximately 70,000m3 of cut, 60,000m3 of fill and 20,000m3 of topsoil stripping over approximately 18ha. Of this 18ha approximately 7.0ha is the Southern Substation, Spoil Disposal Sites and Laydown areas.
Other images relating to risk levels from additional documents are added below. The PDFs follow a similar pattern.
The lower Turitea Stream
Updated July 2022
This letter appears in the August 2022 edition of North and South. We are grateful to have been published in this quality magazine.
Note ‘Stichbury’ is the correct spelling but the mistake was only discovered after printing. North and South has a circulation of 190,000.
https://magazine360.co.nz/publisher/north-and-south-media-ltd/north-south/
PNCC taken to task. Councillors are in recess for July. They have plenty to think about. Do they understand the jeopardy they are in? We’ll find out. They are hiding the potential deaths from a dam collapse, the collapse of the wind farm from NZ’s biggest to NZ’s smallest in a major EQ, and a fake consent. … What a mess!
These show ridges known as shutter ridges which are said to be more dramatic than those on the San Andreas Fault. Contact the Geography Department at Massey to confirm this assessment.
https://www.google.com/maps/search/turitea/@-40.4296957,175.7102518,2285m/data=!3m1!1e3
NZ on Air describes the immense power a fault generates in this very recent video. This is applicable to the Tararua Ranges and Turitea specifically.
May 30 2022
A STUNNING effort to hide all their malfeasance
PNCC has deleted everything on the internet archive prior to January 22 2019
Decades of publicly available files have been buried
https://web.archive.org/web/20190201000000*/https://www.pncc.govt.nz/Home
PNCC went behind citizens backs to force a gigantic wind farm on owners of residential properties, lied and secretly took money to get their way. This is a massive failure by PNCC abrogating its legal obligation to ratepayers of Duty of care under the Law. PNCC allowed subdivision under the wind farm and on the flood plain of the Turitea stream flowing from the dams. They wanted ratepayer revenue.
May 23 2022
These 2017 documents cover the hazards revealed by Water Asset Engineer Dora Luo and her team in a draft report on the safety of the Turitea Dams in an earthquake, potentially killing up to 127 people. Of course the population under the dams in the Turitea has since increased. An additional document estimating the fatalities at various times of day was deleted by PNCC.
Withholding this information is a criminal act.
Luo’s findings are only obliquely referred to in the subsequent Water Safety Plan with a survey – see 13 below – due in 2021. More than four years have passed.
Where is the survey ? Why have the findings not been made public? How was the $1.3 million spent?
Where is Dora Luo? She has acted professionally and responsibly. She appears to have left PNCC.
Did she leave or was she pushed?
This is from the June 2020 Infrastructure Committee. Hardly reassuring.
“3.13 Turitea Dam: the seismic performance of the Upper Turitea Dam is assessed to be
good. A detailed seismic assessment has confirmed a low risk of failure for the Safety
Evaluation Earthquake. While there is residual uncertainty in respect of the upper
dam’s performance, the focus has shifted to how best to mitigate impacts on at risk
properties and public downstream of the dam in the event of a failure.”
Comment
In other words PNCC will send bereavement cards and that’s about it. If they acknowledge the earthquake danger the ludicrous status of the Turitea wind farm is then brought into sharp focus. This would mean breaking the mafia like contract it has with the government which imposes a $3 million penalty on PNCC if it reneges on support for the wind farm.
The dams are now monitored for movement every few days by satellite but this is not a mitigation strategy. It’s to cover their backsides when they claim a catastrophic earthquake was all an act of God and they did their “best.”
Source
Click to access ICCCC_20200603_AGN_9836_AT.PDF
PNCC ratepayers should be holding the Council to account over this scandal.
Two updates below – 8 June 2022
Buried on page 107
“Recent seismic assessment of the main city storage reservoirs has identified major deficiencies in their seismic resilience and confirmed very significant costs required for structural strengthening work. Work will be advanced in 2017/18 on strengthening of the smaller of the two Ngahere Park reservoirs (6,000m3 ), however a decision will need to be made on whether to strengthen or replace the larger 9,000m3 reservoir which is also earthquake prone.”
Note the reservoirs are on relatively flat land some distance below the dams. The reservoirs are obviously at risk of collapse in an earthquake. No mention is made of the dams!
An additional discovery – see page 11.
Dora Luo reveals at an engineers meeting PNCC can’t decide what to tell property owners downstream should the Turitea dams fail. What, if anything, have they been told??
“Potential inundation mapping has resulted in challenging discussions within Council
regarding whether and how we should communicate with the affected property
owners and how it is going to affect the Council’s duty of care under the Law”
The wind farm will go down with the dams but that’s the “Green new deal” in action. Both are now indelibly linked to the threat of a catastrophic earthquake.
Up to 127 deaths possible in a dam failure with many houses swept away.
Seismic issues are becoming much more widely recognised. This should be ringing alarm bells.
Here is the latest May 11 2022
Update 9 May 2022
Letter to Simon Bridges
Update 11 February 2022
The Environment Court has abjectly failed to deal with the Kenderdine fraud where Shonagh Kenderdine faked being a judge for 13 months and issued an illegal consent for the Turitea wind farm. All the evidence you need is linked in this email to all Environment Court judges. The NZ legal system is a total disgrace.
Update 15 January 2022
Assessment of Environmental
Effects – Landscape & Visual
Assessment
A landscape document was prepared for Karen Price of Chancery Green by Environmental Resources Management, Australia in early 2007 -8 but not delivered until August 2008.
This secret document was withheld from submitters so they knew virtually nothing about the wind farm when submissions were to be made during the end of the 2009 summer vacation [when many victims were away]
Had submitters seen this document they would have been able to shred it in their submissions. We have just found it on the internet archive where it had been saved only once.
In the meantime one of the leading forces behind the Turitea corruption, Nick Smith who forced the Call-In, is now using his family firm Smith Cranes to install the turbines. Obviously he secretly planned all along to monetise his involvement. His story is told here. Note he mockingly complains of democracy under threat and makes this delusional statement.
“If I had the choice between journalists who ask nasty questions and who write nasty stories that sometimes hurt a bit, and a country that turns a blind eye to the abuse of power and corruption, I’d much rather have it the way we do.”
https://www.newsroom.co.nz/nick-smith-engineering-a-new-life
https://web.archive.org/web/20220115151400/https://www.newsroom.co.nz/nick-smith-engineering-a-new-life
The article has also been saved as a pdf
Click to access nick-smith-engineering-a-new-life-1.pdf
And of course Kenderdine the criminal fake “judge” and darling of the deep state is receiving enhanced superannuation while her victims face property devaluations that keep them up at night.
Mercury now wants to tear up the conditions Ms Kenderdine “agreed to.”
Update 11 July 2021
No wind farm can survive this
Updated 21 June 2021/ 23 May 2022
https://web.archive.org/web/20150203230846/http://www.chancerygreen.com/index.php/what-we-do/our-projects/mighty-river-power-turitea-wind-farm
http://www.stuff.co.nz/sunday-star-times/business/5033713/Law-system-a-laughing-stock
Archived Stuff article
https://www.nbr.co.nz/article/outraged-finlayson-says-judge-critic-tony-molloy-should-quit-qc-rank
Archived NBR article where Finlayson attacks Molloy
Updated 21 May 2021
The NZ Judiciary is an international laughing stock. Victims of the Turitea Wind Farm Fraud have the opportunity to join those flocking to this petition to speak their minds and nail Shonagh Kenderdine and her corrupt supporters.
https://www.change.org/p/united-nations-high-commissioner-for-human-rights-3221-complaints-made-against-nz-judges-and-not-one-formally-disciplined?redirect=false
Share the Petition.
Latest news article
https://tewahanui.nz/crime-And-justice/petition-calls-for-laws-to-enable-crackdown-on-judges-misconduct
Updated 26 October 2020
This site will continue to be maintained periodically to record the criminality of those running a banana republic.
To the many visitors it is over to you to take whatever legal action you see fit. Expect to be lied to and fobbed off. We are now simply distant observers of the destruction of the city’s natural environment & ratepayer amenity and equity and glad to have left.
To the Crown Law Office 20 May 2020
To The Crown Law Office 25 April 2019 (1) (1)
From the journal of the Resource Management Law Association of New Zealand Inc.
Letter to Solicitor-General Una Jagose QC 24 May 2019 (3)
NB this letter was seen 437 times. Other parties are now following up on this fraud. The fixer was Ben Thomas
Bios here
(5) Ben Thomas _ LinkedIn (1)
(5) Jacob McSweeny _ LinkedIn (1)
5190207_OIA from Paul Stichbury re_ The Turitea Fraud (Wind Farm Palmers… (1) (1)
5275640_Response to 24 May 2019 OIA request from P Stichbury – 24 June 2… (2)
Twitter account exposing the fraud on Palmerston North ratepayers – over 260,000 views – the vast majority by the fraudsters [Govt, judiciary, Mercury and government spy agencies]
N.B.Also includes new material to be one day incorporated into the Kindle version.
Note 1/ No legal action has been taken against us or this Twitter account [other than to suppress it] It like this website tells the unvarnished truth with full supporting documentation.
Note 2/ As you can view this site tell others trying to get access to use a VPN or the Opera browser with its built in VPN.
[numerous documents continue to be downloaded every day]
More here
Note – every avenue for redress has been tried. This is an historical record.
http://newzealandjusticeandpolitics.weebly.com
Archived version [the site was hacked]
https://web.archive.org/web/20191210191158/http://newzealandjusticeandpolitics.weebly.com/
Numerous references to Karen Price have been deleted – these survive.
https://web.archive.org/web/20200216131907/https://iclg.com/firms/chancery-green/karen-price
https://web.archive.org/web/20190112084747/http://hot-topic.co.nz/the-green-green-grass-of-home/
Others requiring preservation
http://www.stuff.co.nz/sunday-star-times/business/5033713/Law-system-a-laughing-stock
https://www.nbr.co.nz/article/outraged-finlayson-says-judge-critic-tony-molloy-should-quit-qc-rank
Click to access app-8-new-assess-of-pncc-policies-objectives.pdf
Click to access capability_statement2013-chancery-green.pdf
From a recent email to another party
This is what we faced – the so called Scottish model of govt where if you complain to any branch of govt you are in fact complaining to the entire govt which then puts up the shutters. We realized this but with perseverance we were able to trap them not only in their lies but also to wring out a confession from the judicial conduct commissioner that Kenderdine was fraudulently posing as a judge.
The Scottish model is covered from 38mins 53 secs
Kenderdine appointed under the District Courts Act 1947 – Act since repealed by Judith Collins to hide the fact that Kenderdine was a fake judge for 13 months
District Courts Act 1947
http://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1947/0016/latest/versions.aspx
Archived record of Kenderdine’s August 2006 farewell. [Deleted from the Resource Management Law Association website – is that a surprise?] http://www.rmla.org.nz/upload/files/rmla_october_2006_newsletter.pdf
Click to access rmla_october_2006_newsletter.pdf
To The Crown Law Office 25 April 2019
Complaint
ChanceryGreen opened by Helen Clark
Green Investment Fund
Updated 30/12/2018
Links to additional tweets which unlock important threads
Links to earlier tweets now hidden
To The Prime Minister 13 November 2018
Winston Peters office replies 7 Jan 2013
An astounding development re the Turitea wind farm – email to Winston Peters 6 Jan 2013
To The Prime Minister 27 September 2018
Bill Harding Electrical Systems Diagnostic Engineer 1 Sept 2018
Bill Harding 2 October 2018
Kenderdine’s fraudulent website – archived
https://web.archive.org/web/20181030234427/https://shonaghkenderdine.wordpress.com/about/
New – a comprehensive summary in pdf form for your PC or Kindle. Please share this widely as this website is blocked in New Zealand
Kindle version
*********
Futuna Trust Kenderdine a Dame
Whaleoil deletes and alters my comments
Gascoigne letter
(1)Complaint to the New Zealand Law Society Karen Price
(5)Law Society Response
(1)RESPONSE TO THE DECISION BY THE WELLINGTON STANDARDS COMMITTEE 3
1)Les Taylor QC’s defence
Response to Mr Taylor QC re Karen Price complaint.
LCRO 13 January 2015
(6)20150703150907735
NB Within 24 hours I lodged a complaint with Disqus over Whaleoil deleting and then impersonating me. The email below addresses the move by Finlayson to shut down criticism of judges – i.e covering for his and Collin’s extensive involvement covering up the Kenderdine fraud.
Email to Slater
Slater replies within a couple of minutes and lies from his bully pulpit
Slater visits http://newzealandjusticeandpolitics.weebly.com/
Earlier engagement with Cameron Slater on Whaleoil regarding Kenderdine -see Zorro
Backup http://archive.is/C1DyH
Slater was fully aware of the Kenderdine fraud
http://disq.us/p/122joi3
http://disq.us/p/122k74l
In 2009 Attorney General Chris Finlayson appointed Barber as an acting district court judge to help reduce caseloads in the civil and criminal courts.
He would have been 72 at the time – two years older than the mandatory retirement age for judges in New Zealand.
However, under section 10 of the District Courts Act 1947 a former judge who has reached the age of 70 years may be appointed for a period of up to one year, or for two or more periods not exceeding four years in the aggregate. But Section 10 also specifies that each appointment must not exceed one year if the person is 72-years-old as in Barber’s case.
https://www.whaleoil.co.nz/2015/10/212755/
The Commonwealth legal fraternity has been informed of the corruption inflicted on New Zealand.
Submission
the-20th-commonwealth-law-conference-melbourne-2017
Finlayson and his cronies have been outed. The two New Zealand spy agencies are charged with keeping the Turitea fraud under the radar. Look at who is in charge.
Click here to enlarge
“Journalism is printing what someone else does not want printed: everything else is public relations,” George Orwell.
The Turitea fraud – key points – see essay below
1. The media co-opted into defrauding our city – reporters fear for their jobs if they transgress Fairfax’s political stance
2. Secret contracts perverting the course of justice, but now available on this website Link Link
3. Environmental desecration on an epic scale to “save the planet”
4. Judicial fraud by Shonagh Kenderdine with the connivance of the Attorney-General Chris Finlayson and knowledge of all NZ govt Cabinet Ministers. Huge, illegal and corrupt payments made to participants, in particular Kenderdine, paid to pretend she was a judge. Kenderdine contravened both the Crimes Act Part 6
The Crimes Act 1961 part 6 contains criminal offences related to, amongst other things, the corrupt use of official information and the corruption and bribery of:
- the Judiciary
- ministers of the Crown
- members of Parliament
- law enforcement officers
- public officials.
and the Secret Commissions Act 1910. Maximum penalties range from 7 to 14 years in jail. The collusion by Karen Price, the supervision of this crime by Attorney-General Finlayson and Minister Nick Smith, the cover-up by Judith Collins, the perjury by Mark Henry and Douglas Heffernan would additionally put them and others behind bars.
New Zealand’s unjustified high ranking on the International Corruption Index is under threat
The rule of law also forms a significant part of the New Zealand constitution. The principles of the rule of law are not easily defined but encompass ideas such as:
- the powers exercised by parliamentarians and officials are based on legal authority;
- a person should not be deprived of his or her liberty, status or other substantial interest without the opportunity of a fair hearing before an impartial court or tribunal.
- The theoretical purity spouted by the Ministry of Justice
5. Scandalous cronyism – involving lawyer Karen Price, who will clip the carbon trading ticket [including for PNCC], and securities fraud by those handling the Mighty River Power IPO
6. The pervasive, pernicious influence of the UN – the Turitea farce originates from former NZ Prime Minister Helen Clark
7. Non science based obsession with harmless CO2. President Trump is kicking this fraud to the curb. IPCC abandons the scientific method
8. Fraud on Mighty River Power investors by multiple parties and government agencies
9. Earthquake “denial” – the Turitea and Puketoi wind farms and substations and pylons”approved” right on top of three of the country’s major fault lines – the Wellington, Northern Ohariu and Wairarapa faults [Makuri-Waewaepa]
10. The NZ judicial system and legal profession a cesspit
Read it here – full supporting links provided
The Turitea Wind Farm – a journey through a labyrinth of lies
THE ESSAY ABOVE HAS BEEN REVIEWED BY A VERY SENIOR AND RESPECTED NZ PUBLIC SERVANT WHO COMMENTED THAT IT WAS “SOBERING AND ALARMING”
[Includes the corrupt role played by Karen Price of law firm ChanceryGreen and her mentor, ally and supervisor, Helen Clark, after the position of United Nations Secretary-General]
Clark addressing the UN in a futile effort to persuade them she is an “untainted” candidate. The NZ Herald advances 10 reasons she failed , blissfully unaware that the indisputable facts on this website showing her Turitea corruption were viewed multiple times by her opponents.
Hillary Clinton, the most corrupt, criminal candidate to ever to run for the White House is a bosom buddy of Helen Clark’s. Clark’s name appears in the Wikileaks Clinton emails. The NZ govt funded her campaign to be Secretary General. Prosecutions loom for the Clinton Foundation fraudsters
The New Zealand Government anxious to buy access to a Clinton crime syndicate led Globalist, NWO administration contributed $7.7 million to the Clinton Foundation with a promise of a further $6 million
Ex Prime Minister John Key submitting to Hillary Clinton
His mates rally round
You are free to publish/repost/link the above document to your website
Now featured here
LINK
And here
Update [1] to the document above. The judgement against the Friends of The Turitea Reserve Incorporated v Palmerston North City Council [July 2007] was withheld from litigants but discovered online 28 April 2016. It’s no surprise why. [ NB the Judge in this case is David Baragwanath who as a young prosecutor worked with lawyer John Henry in trying to keep Arthur Allan Thomas locked up for a murder he did not commit] Baragwanath was knighted in 2011. The judgement linked below is now available on the Ministry for Justice website. but you need to search for it.
Judgment – The friends of Turitea Reserve
Setting a trap
Update [2] to the document above. The Government got Google to delete www.palmerstonnorth.blogspot.com in 2010. This illegality, discovered April, 2016 is recorded on the internet archive.
LINK
Update [3] to the document above. Link [8] in the document leads to a RadioLive interview where MRP CEO Heffernan lies to the NZ public about the wind farm. The audio has been deliberately disabled. All you need is here.
Heffernan lies to the Board
NB. Heffernan passes GO and collects $500,000
Update [4] to the document above. This video [July 2014], recently recovered [1/8/2016], shows how the New Zealand Law Society covered up criminality and fraud by Shonagh Kenderdine and her government supervisors. The last 3 years of her “professional” history were “disappeared.” The web site featured here no longer exists [is that a surprise?]
Update [5] to the document above. After being hauled before the Law Society Karen Price’s reputation is so toxic to ChanceryGreen, the Law firm she owned, that she sold it in September 2016 but acts as a consultant to it.
Update [6] Respected, veteran campaigner, Alison Mildon, is lied to by PNCC
Complaint to the New Zealand Law Society 7 July 2014
Note: several links in the document above no longer work but the documents referred to however are available on this website.
A lament
Here come I, t’is Kenderdine
I am Mistress of this Court
No warrant needed, just a gown
So suck it up, you peasant clowns
Glass ceilings I hit many times
The scars that left, well they are mine
Tokens of thanks from Mother Earth
Whose crags and valleys my face reflects
But smoothed by funds from those I served
And gongs on walls well reinforced
By the very bullshit I enforced
Blatant fraudster
The indisputable proof of judicial and government corruption and malfeasance.
Sir David Gascoigne, Judicial Conduct Commissioner.
Click to enlarge.
Gascoigne lied about Kenderdine’s immunity from prosecution. Not only did Kenderdine break the Secret Commissions act 1910 but the Crimes Act 1961 which is specific concerning crimes by the judiciary
The Turitea Final Decision is illegal and corrupt.
Kenderdine, global warming fanatic, “a judge for hire” was fraudulently passing herself off as a judge when she had been permanently removed from the judiciary on 6 August 2010 and had not held a warrant for 13 months before the Final Decision was issued on 6 September 2011.
Kenderdine’s farewell in 2006
TURITEA CONSENT ISSUES
THE TURITEA WIND FARM ERRORS AND OMISSIONS.
Kenderdine lies about her time as a judge on her website as she touts for business. Unbelievable arrogance and an own goal!
****
Kenderdine deletes her website, August 2016
https://en.wordpress.com/typo/?subdomain=skenderdine
ORIGINAL HERE, OR SEE ABOVE
Nick Smith’s deep involvement in the Turitea wind farm fraud
Letter to Dr Smith 6 June 2015
Reply from Dr Smith 12 August 2015
Judicial Warrants Dr Smith
MRP PNCC contract Dr Smith
NO REPLY FROM SMITH TO THE ABOVE
Mighty River Power knives the “pre-conditioned” city in the back
MRP’s full submission see P36
MRP Submission and Archive
FOR A SUMMARY OF EVENTS MADE EARLIER VISIT
http://nzwindfarms.wordpress.com
FOR A SUMMARY OF LEGAL ISSUES VISIT
http://tothehighcourt.weebly.com/
COMPLAINT LAID WITH THE NEW ZEALAND LAW SOCIETY
Complaint to the New Zealand Law Society 7 July 2014
REPLY FROM THE NEW ZEALAND LAW SOCIETY 8 JULY 2014
RESPONSE TO THE NEW ZEALAND LAW SOCIETY 9 JULY 2014
REPLY FROM THE NEW ZEALAND LAW SOCIETY 15 JULY 2014
NEWS FLASH
UPDATE FINAL VERSION
10/4/2013
LETTER TO THE PRIME MINISTER 23 MARCH 2014
Attorney-General Finlayson is above the law and supervised Kenderdine’s crime spree
Kenderdine’s term as Chair of the Historic Places Trust expired in July 2013 but as of May 22 2014 she was still there under Finlayson’s “protection” by fraudulently, illegally and secretly extending her term.
“He has also used his executive powers to make more High Court applications seeking litigants be prevented court access on grounds they are vexatious than in the prior 60 years.”
This bodes poorly for anyone challenging this fraud and corruption. Expect to be silenced.
Napoleon seized the crown from the Pope and Finlayson gave himself a QC warrant. You just couldn’t make this **** up
On 13 December 2012, Finlayson recommended himself for appointment as Queen’s Counsel by the Governor-General,[6] based on his role as Attorney-General.[7]
After Finlayson was challenged over his involvement in this fraud the link to the page, screencapped below, which was sent to him 26 August 2013 [See letter below or this link] was deleted from the Government’s Ministry for Culture and Heritage website.
http://www.mch.govt.nz/funding-nz-culture/agencies-we-fund/heritage/new-zealand-historic-places-trust
It was saved however 17 times on the internet archive.
https://web.archive.org/web/20130206092952/http://www.mch.govt.nz/funding-nz-culture/agencies-we-fund/heritage/new-zealand-historic-places-trust
Inerasable additional proof
https://www.gazette.govt.nz/notice/id/2010-go6556
https://web.archive.org/web/20151209031451/https://www.gazette.govt.nz/notice/id/2010-go6556
KENDERDINE’S APPOINTMENT
Finlayson totally fails to obey the explicit directives in the Cabinet Manual setting out his duties as Attorney-General
Role of Attorney-General
Law officer role
4.3The Attorney-General has particular responsibility for maintaining the rule of law. The Attorney-General has a responsibility to notify Cabinet of any proposals or government actions that do not comply with existing law and to propose action to remedy such matters.
Link between the judiciary and the government
4.8The Attorney-General is the link between the judiciary and executive government. The Attorney-General recommends the appointment of judges and has an important role in defending the judiciary by answering improper and unfair public criticism, and discouraging ministerial colleagues from criticising judges and their decisions.
http://www.cabinetmanual.cabinetoffice.govt.nz/4.2
Did Finlayson provide a legal basis endorsing the Kenderdine fraud? No, he most certainly did not. See correspondence below
Kenderdine got paid [took bribes] for being a fake judge. So what exactly does the SECRET COMMISSIONS ACT have to say about that??
Secret Commissions Act 1910
LINK
A person who commits an offence against this Act is liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 7 years.
Finlayson, as Attorney-General, removed Kenderdine’s warrant and her name from the judicial roll but to this day covers up fraud and corruption.
rmla_october_2006_newsletter
KENDERDINE APPOINTED FOR THE FIRST OF THE ALLOWED 2 YEAR TERMS AFTER RETIREMENT
KENDERDINE APPOINTED FOR THE SECOND AND FINAL OF THE ALLOWED 2 YEAR TERMS AFTER RETIREMENT
Kenderdine’s farewell in 2006
Kenderdine NOT a judge and Governor-General Satyanand her one time colleague knew this full well.
The lies continue on the MFE website.
Kenderdine’s lies exposed by Marlborough District Council, August 1 2013.
SOURCE
Kenderdine’s corrupt farce, based on IPCC climate “models”, is ripped up in the AR5 summary of likely outcomes. Polar bears and sea level rise don’t even make the list. Are politicians going to tell the truth?
SOURCE
Below is a sample of documentation.
Now if you want to commit a crime and don’t want to get caught this is what you do:
1/ Become a member of Parliament.
2/ Claim immunity when you pretend to be a judge
3/ Circle the wagons with your mates’ help. Look the other way when they break the law to line your pockets – see 5th November letter.
4/ Ignore all the key issues raised.
5/ Get Google, the NZSIS and the GCSB to cover your backside.
*
Finlayson, Attorney-General, is unfit to hold public office
The legal definition of collusion:
“An agreement between two or more people to defraud a person of his or her rights or to obtain something that is prohibited by law.
A secret arrangement wherein two or more people whose legal interests seemingly conflict conspire to commit Fraud upon another person; a pact between two people to deceive a court with the purpose of obtaining something that they would not be able to get through legitimate judicial channels.”
http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/collusion
LETTER TO HON.C.FINLAYSON 5 NOVEMBER 2013.
*
LETTER TO HON AMY ADAMS 23 SEPTEMBER 2013.
*
HON AMY ADAMS REPLIES 20 SEPTEMBER 2013
*
LETTER TO HON.C.FINLAYSON 12 SEPTEMBER 2013
*
The only response ever received from Finlayson
Hon C Finlayson responds 11 September 2013
*
LETTER TO HON.C.FINLAYSON 26 AUGUST 2013
*
LETTER TO POLICE 18 JUNE 2013
LETTER TO GOVERNOR-GENERAL’S SECRETARY 16 JUNE 2013
LETTER TO HON C.FINLAYSON 20 APRIL 2013 FORWARDED TO THE GOVERNOR-GENERAL’S SECRETARY
Judith Collins lies to the Governor-General. See letter below.
LETTER TO HON.C.FINLAYSON 20 APRIL 2013
LETTER TO HON DR SMITH 15 APRIL 2013
According to Dr Smith providing incontrovertible evidence of fraud and corruption are “over the top claims” He’s been caught and he’s circling the wagons in his ridiculous response to John Adams’ February 13 letter.
Mr Plod replies and has since been sent detailed information only the North Korean government could ignore.
Judith Collins, now Minister of Police, has never replied to any letter. She is a lawyer and unfit to hold public office.
LETTER TO JUDITH COLLINS MINISTER OF JUSTICE 8 APRIL 2013
LETTER TO HON.C.BORROWS 26 MARCH 2013
LETTER TO HON SIMON BRIDGES 21 MARCH 2013
PLUS ATTACHMENT
JUDICIAL WARRANTS
LETTER TO MRP 21 MARCH 2013
LETTER TO CPEC 20 MARCH 2013
LETTER TO SFO 12 MARCH 2013
LETTER TO POLICE 6 MARCH 2013
LETTER TO THE QUEEN 22 FEBRUARY 2013
PLUS
LETTER TO THE GOVERNOR GENERAL 29 JANUARY 2013
LETTER TO NZILA 21 FEBRUARY 2013
James Miller a board member of both Mighty River Power and the Financial Markets Authority. An outrageous conflict of interest. NZX board [2010] currently Chairman. See Tony Ryall’s unsolicited response.
HERE
Others are paying attention
James Millar
LETTER TO THE FINANCIAL MARKETS AUTHORITY 18 FEBRUARY 2013
letter to Hon. Dr Smith 13 February 2013 (1)
Hudson response. page 1 Hudson response. page two
OUT COMES THE WHITEWASH!!
LIKE THE TURITEA “CONSENT” THE NZILA’S CODE OF ETHICS IS NOT WORTH THE PAPER IT’S WRITTEN ON.
****
ONCE “RENT A JUDGE” KENDERDINE NO LONGER HAD A WARRANT THE BOI CEASED TO EXIST AS SUCH AND WE HAD A GROUP OF RENT SEEKERS, HUDSON INCLUDED, TURNING UP FOR THE NEXT 13 MONTHS LIKE TAME DRUGGED CHOOKS TO COLLECT THEIR “PAY” i.e. “BRIBES.” A LOT OF PEOPLE KNEW WHAT WAS GOING ON.
****
COMPLAINT OF FRAUD LODGED WITH THE SERIOUS FRAUD OFFICE 2 JANUARY 2013
A TISSUE OF LIES AND A FRAUDULENT TURITEA WIND FARM CONSENT – 2 JANUARY 2013
RESPONSE FROM THE GOVERNMENT 14 DECEMBER 2012
LETTER & EMAIL TO THE MINISTER OF JUSTICE, RT HON JUDITH COLLINS 13 DECEMBER 2012
THE TURITEA WIND FARM ERRORS AND OMISSIONS.
LETTER EXPOSING A CRIMINAL ACT 10 December 2012
LETTER TO THE ENVIRONMENT COURT 7 DECEMBER 2012
SCOOP RELEASE
21 January 2013
A major development arising from the corrupt Turitea Final Decision. Mighty River Power must inform the investing public with specific detail that the Turitea and Puketoi wind farms are right on three of the country’s major fault lines. Turitea is on the Wellington and Northern Ohariu faults and Puketoi is right on the Wairarapa fault
Click to enlarge
PNCC employees beaver away on the ratepayer’s dime to shaft the very people they are meant to serve.
Response from PNCC under the OIA
Hudson being held to account – see paragraph 9 in this letter to the New Zealand Institute of Landscape Architects,10 Nov 2012
Letter of complaint to IPENZ – 5 Nov 2012 – IPENZ circled their wagons around commissioner David Bunting and attempted a whitewash, but all they did was “tug on Superman’s cape”
PNCC responds, 30 October 2012 – so do victims pay twice? – let’s see how this plays out – all great due diligence for the inevitable court case and application for future discovery
Email to Palmerston North City Council Legal Dept and Councillors 29 October 2012
A victory for common sense – so long as Mighty River Power complies in full.
Heffernan reply Oct 2012
Letter to the Prime Minister, the Rt Hon John Key 16 October 2012
letter to Hon. C.Finlayson 15 October 2012
Shonagh Kenderdine the activist.
letter to Dr. Heffernan 25 sept. 2012
letter to Law Commission 15 Sept. 2012
letter to Hon. A.Adams 31 August 2012
Reply to Civil Defence 16th July
Reply from Civil Defence 16th July 2012
letter to law commission 16 July 2012
letter to regulations review committee 14 July 2012
Email to Ministry of Civil Defence July 4 2012
letter to Hon. Amy Adams 2 July 2012
From the Financial Markets Authority May 15
To the FMA 15 May
To the FMA May 9
To The Financial Marketing Authority
Claims by Mighty River Power to be a good corporate citizen
Contact form FMA May 7
letter to Hon. C. Finlayson 6 June 2012
letter from C.Finlayson 30 May 2012
letter from T.Ryall 4 May 2012 page 1
letter from T.Ryall 4 May 2012 page 2
letter to Hon Dr Smith 11 May2012
letter from N.Smith 4 May 2012
letter to Ombudsman 29 April 2012
Email correspondence to the Office of the Auditor General from 24/4/2012
Office of the Controller and Auditor-General
The Office of Controller and Auditor-General is central to ensuring the accountability of the public sector. Part of its role is to look closely at the way the public sector uses its money and to report any corrupt use to Parliament.
Office of Controller and Auditor-General(external link)
The office has 2 units:
- Office of the Auditor-General
- Audit New Zealand.
The Auditor-General independently reports on whether public organisations are behaving financially appropriately and are giving full and accurate accounts of their activities.
The Public Audit Act also gives the Auditor-General significant powers to access information.
These powers ensure there is a high degree of transparency surrounding the use of public money. These transparent arrangements are one of the reasons New Zealand is consistently seen as having low levels of corruption.
Audit New Zealand carries out auditing of all types of public sector organisations. An independent body, it enables domestic and international confidence in the thorough and unbiased investigations of New Zealand’s public sector finances.
Purpose to alert this office to the potential fraud on investors, unaware that Mighty River Power’s wind farms are approved right on earthquake fault lines.
To the Office of The Auditor
Response from The Office of the Auditor -General 30 April
Reply to Ms Hutton 30 April.
Response from The Office of the Auditor -General 1 May
Reply to Ms Hutton 1 May
**
Cost to taxpayers of the Board of Inquiry released under the Official Information Act 26/4/2012
$2,043,394.00
It appears that Shonagh Kenderdine has been paid approximately $400,000 ++ to shaft both Palmerston North and the Tararua District.
Paul Stichbury OIA Response
By accepting this posted comment the Manawatu Standard has admitted culpability. See comment 4
http://www.stuff.co.nz/manawatu-standard/opinion/6784747/Editorial-Simple-matter-of-integrity
letter to Attorney and Solicitor General 22 April 2012
Earlier Turitea Wind Farm Documents.
The Turitea Wind Farm Final Decision is faulty on numerous levels. Every effort has been made behind the scenes to resolve the issues raised in the correspondence posted here, but these efforts have failed. The Turitea Board of Inquiry and the now retired chair, former Judge, Shonagh Kenderdine, [subsequently proven to be faking judicial authority as a member of the public without a warrant], ignored all submissions relating to these matters, which are now being put in the public arena to bring a resolution. The sell off of SOE’s, in particular Mighty River Power, is bringing these matters into sharp focus.
Each issue is dealt with separately. The correspondence below is between the Environment Court, the Environmental Protection Authority and the office of the Minister for the Environment.
-
The foundation document for the wind farm is based on fraud. Palmerston North ratepayers have had their rights as property owners cancelled by the formerly secret contract between PNCC and Mighty River Power, which overturns the Local Government Act 2002. This contract is on the MFE website.
Letter re PNCC MRP contract
The full contract.
christopher-shaw-attachment-1-part-a
-
The wind farm has been approved on two of the country’s most dangerous fault lines.
Turitea seismic issues
See page 10 for Alexander’s seismic “evidence”.
gavin-alexander-appendix-1
The Board does not ask any questions about the fault lines.
Evidence Aleaxander
-
The noise standard for wind farms has been created by the industry itself
Turitea wind farm noise issues and NZS6808 2010
Appendix 1 Christchurch Press on the noise standard
Appendix 2 Revisit noise standards Christchurch Press
Appendix 1 Dr Thorne noise report 15 june 2011
Professor Dickinson’s protests released under the OIA.
-
Safety issues
safety issues.Pahiatua Track –
-
“Deliberate” errors in the report.
To the Environmental Protection Agency. Deliberate errors 19.10.2011
-
Selective compensation.
Appendix 2 Compensation issues (A)
Appendix 2 Compensation issues Wheeler (B)
- .
Impact of transmission lines
Turitea Puketoi Transmission Lines.
-
An unanswered complaint
Complaint re Judge Kenderdine
-
The Board fails to address issues of spying by Mighty River Power.
evidence-of-mrp-suppressing-information-and-allegedly-hacking-computers
The final attempt at a whitewash
Letter to Paul Stichbury – 12 October 2011
To the Environmental Protection Agency 15 Oct 2011
Letter – Mr Stichbury – 27 Oct 11
To the Environmental Protection Authority 30 October 2011
Note: Dr Smith mentions only one fault line and avoids the issue of
the contract between PNCC and MRP.
THE FRAUDULENT TURITEA CHANGE OF PURPOSE CONSULTATION DOCUMENT DISTRIBUTED TO PN HOUSEHOLDS IN AUGUST 2006 AND WHICH HAS DISAPPEARED FROM THE WEB. FORTUNATELY WE SAVED A COPY AND YOU CAN ACCESS IT HERE.
ReserveConsultationweb
Additional information: Link to RadioLive interview in which CEO Douglas Heffernan lies about the size of the Turitea Wind Farm.
The New Zealand Green Party strongly opposes the Turitea wind farm,
479palmerstonnorthbranchgreenpartyaotearoanz
There has been a huge volume of correspondence relating to the deliberate negligence and poor conduct by Kenderdine and her board members. Here is just a sample of this correspondence, which has been ignored.
letter to chief justice 27 January 2012
letter to Dr Nick Smith 29 September 2011
letter to Judge Newhook 21 September 2011
letter to Judge Newhook 22 September 2011 (1)
letter to Judge Newhook 23 September 2011
letter to Judge Newhook 24 September 2011
letter to Judge Newhook 26 September 2011
Letter to judge Newhook 27 September 2011
letter to Judge Newhook 28 September 2011
letter to Judicial Complaints Commissioner 26 March 2012
letter to ministers 3 April 2012 (1)
letter to ministers 3 April 2012
Kenderdine literally believes the world will end around 2040
Google helps to hide Kenderdine’s corrupt decision. A Google search for Shonagh Kenderdine produces this result – what a pathetic shielding of this arrogant, money grubbing, anti democratic tosser.
This Google search produces this result. The NZ Govt hard at work covering up.
The Truth is Out…………… – Palmerston North.info
20 Jun 2012 … A stunning development in this saga of corruption and fraud, Shonagh
Kenderdine was all along pretending to be an authorised judge with a …
Turitea wind farmer wants to hide the fact that the wind farm is on two fault lines
twenty-bad-things-about-wind-energy
Palmerston North visit 858 by MRP
Turitea Board of Inquiry Protocols
Guidelines-for-Judicial-Conduct
NZILA Code of professional conduct
ENVIRONMENTAL CRIMINALS – THEY ALL KNEW KENDERDINE WAS NOT A JUDGE WHEN THEY SIGNED OFF ON A FRAUD
BECA CARTER SEISMIC SURVEY – TURITEA
Palmerston North liquefaction_report_2011
Joseph Poff stands for Horizons. His self serving statements as a candidate are evidence of how destructive the Turitea wind farm fraud, with which he has been intimately involved, has impacted the community. He claims to have no conflict of interest – pull the other one, Joseph! This has been saved in case it “disappears”.
Mighty River Power checks Joseph Poff
turiteawatersupplybook see page 14 for detail on the fractured rock discovered when dam building.
document has been denied. No surprise as to why.
PNCC documents deleted but retrieved from the internet archive – all part of the elaborate fraud.
Kahuterwa outdoor recreation plan – part 1 10-6-08
Kahuterwa outdoor recreation plan part 2 10-6-08
Kahuterawa outdoor recreation plan-development-map
Kahuterawa outdoor recreation plan -location-map
Kahuterawa outdoor recreation plan -resource-context-map
Kahuterawa outdoor recreation -woodpecker-development-map
Palmerston North natural hazards as perceived in 2000
All buildings in Palmerston North as identified in accordance with the Building Act 2004 and constructed pre 1976,
or as otherwise identified by Council (e.g. processing of applications) are to be assessed.
Tararua District earthquake prone buildings
16-sept-directions-from-judge page 14 no noise conditions for Tararua
Guidelines-for-Judicial-Conduct-March-2013
EC_Registrars_Report_2010 kenderdine
EC_Registrar_Report_2011 Kenderdine
The New Zealand system of Government is based on the Westminster model
Judicial conduct and Kenderdine’s failures
Email to PNCC re transmission route to Turitea 29 12 2012
Mighty_River_Power_Share_Offer_Document
Turitea in the Mighty River Power share offer document
ChrisTaylorpaper Algal bloom Turitea
http://www.stuff.co.nz/manawatu-standard/8212899/Wind-farm-consents-validity-questioned-by-opponents
Final Decision Turitea volume-1
Karen Price disguised her involvement with Puketoi
Current global climate statistics January 2014
Admissibility of evidence before the Turitea Board of Inquiry
blame Horizons for the inevitable disastrous outcome of the Board of Inquiry
TURITEA RESERVE SUBMISSION WORKSHOP
code-for-expert-witnesses-ignored-by-kenderdine
There are important points to be made about this presentation.
- The workshop was held just 10 days before submissions closed. Why? Slides 1 and 2
- Wide community participation sought, (well that’s interesting! When, exactly?) – so the blame for a poor outcome will then rest with the Board of Enquiry, and not PNCC – no community participation has been encouraged until now. Why? Slide 3
- Most significant resource consent application concerning Palmerston North’s environment in 50 years or more . . . .! Why has this stunning statement been made just 10 days out from the closing of submissions? Slide 4
- “Decision makers take notice of community views” The track record of many consent hearings to date, show the complete opposite. The Council for reasons already discussed handed over the city to a commercial arm of the Government. Did PNCC fail to exhibit duty of care by believing that it could pass the responsibility of its partnership with MRP on to RMA Commissioners? Slide 8
- The contract with MRP had been signed and money paid before the change of purpose submissions even opened. This does not sit well with my idea of what I consider to be either just or fair. PNCC’s wind farm analysis has never been made public. Slide 35
- The proponents and beneficiaries of this scheme have been in collaboration from the start, a courtesy that was not extended to other nearby residents who would potentially be affected. Only at the eleventh hour are residents urged to “collaborate,” by PNCC after being previously ignored misled and dragged into the courtroom.. Slide 60 00
Ministry of Justice search for Kenderdine (4)
Ministry of Justice search for Kenderdine (3)
Ministry of Justice search for Kenderdine (2)
Ministry of Justice search for Kenderdine (1)
Ministry of Justice takes a look
Ministry of Justice concern over Turitea costs
MRP search for traffic meeting minutes
Mighty River Power to impose its will
Turiteadocuments website blocked in New Zealand
potential for judicial corruption
The problem faced by the Elliott family
The London School of Economics survey of house prices affected by wind farm2
The London School of Economics survey of house prices affected by wind farms February 2014
Wind turbines are slashing the value of homes built nearby, according to a new study into the impact of the large structures on property prices.
The study, by the London School of Economics (LSE), reviewed more than a million homes within close proximity of large wind farms over a 12-year period, finding that their property values fell by 11 per cent.
The report’s author, Professor Steve Gibbons, Director of LSE’s Spatial Economics Research Centre, told the the Daily Mail: “Property prices are going up in places where they’re not visible and down in the places where they are.”
Windfarms and House prices November 2013 v5
Variation to the wind farm agreement
Maassen protests at Price’s tactics
PNCC responds
22-june-09-affidavit-of-virginia-shaw
Price manipulating behind the scenes yet again
Karen is recognised as a leader in climate change issues internationally. In 1991 she was part of the NZ delegation to the IPCC negotiations having written a master’s thesis on climate change issues and the dynamics of international negotiations
see
LEANZ_-_Carbon_Markets_26_April_2012 (1)
Ms Tanock for TAG and Friends of the Turitea Reserve
LEANZ_-_Carbon_Markets_26_April_2012 (3)
capability_statement2013 Chancery Green
http://turiteapalmerstonnorth.wordpress.com/
http://turiteapalmerstonnorth.wordpress.com/page/2/
day-1-hearing-schedule Heffernan lies
day-4-hearing-schedule Alexander and earthquakes
day-8-hearing-schedule Landscape report kept from submitters, MOU asked for and withheld
evidence-of-mac-henry See page 30
turitea-forward-executive-summary
Objects of the Resource Management Law Association
turitea-mrp-further-comments-to-board Puketoi transmission
App-8.-New-Assess-of-PNCC-Policies-Objectives
http://web.archive.org/web/20110525100222/http://www.mfe.govt.nz/rma/call-in-turitea/index.html
Click to access turitea-summary-submissions-report.pdf
First submissions
Submissions on the Draft Decision
Redesign submissions
monica-stichbury-236-turitea-wind-farm-draft-decision-comments
stichbury-325-final-submission-turitea-wind-farm-draft-decision
Helen Clark opens Price’s law firm
Finlayson rants
Price Clark Cunliffe ChanceryGreen and comments
Joan Withers Executive profile
Kenderdine gets her “gong”
http://gg.govt.nz/content/judge-shonagh-kenderdine-qso
He shook the hand of a fraud and knew it.
https://web.archive.org/web/20111204045821/http://www.historic.org.nz:80/AboutUs/Board.aspx
Puketoi David Kirkpatrick see page 15 re Stichbury & Adams
propertyrightsdoyouhaveany David Kirk
Response to Mr Taylor QC re Karen Price complaint. LCRO 13 January 2015
Dr Thorne’s report to the Adams – identifies the smear on Dr Phipps see section 6 Matters arising
Google works with the NZ Government, in particular to denigrate Dr Phipps
Judge Baragwanath
Heffernan lies to the Board of Inquiry
Heffernan passes Go and collects $500,000
Photo of Cunliffe’s children whom he claimed in Parliament would become extinct due to climate change. He made this outrageous claim in support of his wife’s carbon trading business when the ETS was not extended.
www://insightnz.wordpress.com/2014/05/12/david-cunliffe-and-wife-karen-an-instant-hit/
Backup
https://web.archive.org/web/20151003212618/https://insightnz.wordpress.com/2014/05/12/david-cunliffe-and-wife-karen-an-instant-hit/
Give us the money or our children die!
All submissions were deleted from the MFE website when a complaint against Karen Price was lodged with the NZ Law Society
https://turiteapalmerstonnorth.wordpress.com/
https://turiteapalmerstonnorth.wordpress.com/page/2/
Check the dates for what you are searching for from the website above
*
The internet archive has them all.
https://web.archive.org/web/*/mfe.govt.nz
Dr David Black shill for the wind farm industry – Turitea, Motorimu etc – mercilessly exposed.
*****
Thesis_critique_March_26_2012(5)David Black exposed
*****
Dr David Black exposed
*****
COMMENT FROM RANGITIKEI GUARDIANS David Black
*****
Black caught out
******
Hot on Black’s tail
******
Hunting Black down
Extra resources for investigative journalists – should this extinct species ever revive.
turitea-summary-submissions-report
Puketoi David Kirkpatrick (1) see page 15 Kirkpatrick now an Environment Court Judge knew Kenderdine was not a judge with the power to issue the Turitea consent
AFFIDAVIT Murray Martin – Noise
Someone smelt a rat
https://web.archive.org/web/20130208160624/http://dialogue.co.nz/News/Entries/2009/8/2_Turitea_wind_farm_evidence_on_social_effects_2.html
revised-rebuttal-evidence-of-peter-phillips
Evidence that on Government instructions Google deleted palmerstonnorth.blogspot in 2010. This was illegal and after about a month Google thought better and the blog was reinstated.
Saved on the internet archive!
https://web.archive.org/web/20100604073607/http://www.palmerstonnorth.blogspot.com/
Back up LINK
Councillor who knew full well that submitters to the change of purpose to the Turitea Reserve were subject to a corrupt and secret contract between MRP and PNCC does his best to cover his involvement
Gordon Cruden covering his tracks
One term Mayor Heather Tanguay and wind farm advocate [left]takes a welcome break from settling Islamic migrants from the Middle East
IWI INVOLVEMENT IN THE FRAUD
Wiremu Te Awe Awe below [left] negotiated what is rumoured to be a multi million dollar payout from Mighty River Power on behalf of Rangitane and Rangiotu Marae as beneficiaries. In effect the local iwi secretly sold the Tararua ranges back to the government so they could plaster it with wind turbines. It’s the Taniwha principle at work. The memorandum between the parties involved was cited as evidence. Kenderdine was asked for it at the Turitea Call-In hearings but it was withheld, and the request ignored. Other Maori voiced their disappointment that they were left out of this bonanza .
Next to Te Awe Awe is Prime Minister John Key. Many of the emails sent to the principal players in the Turitea fraud were also copied to him and ignored.
Next to Key on the right is Jono Naylor, National list MP who as Palmerston North Mayor at the meeting approving the change of purpose to the Turitea Reserve said “There’s gold in them thar hills”
The photo is of Te Awe Awe blessing a Rescue helicopter.
NEWS REPORT
“Rangitane descendant Peter Te Rangi said he was concerned Mighty River Power had considered a Maori perspective on the issue too narrowly.
While Mighty River Power had signed a memorandum of understanding with Rangitane, it had not given the same attention to other iwi.
Tribes such as Ngati Apa also had a deep association with the Turitea range, he said.”
http://www.stuff.co.nz/manawatu-standard/news/2829808/Locals-wind-farm-fears-cast-aside
Shelton just kept quiet about this
Memorandum
Wind farmer Joseph Poff who stood for Council despite an illegal conflict of interest [and was soundly defeated] rails against opponents of the Turitea wind farm.
The Secret Commissions Act plus evidence
price-outed-secret-commissions-act-1910
pncc-deliberately-puts-up-obstacles
kenderdine-lectures-on-earthquakes
roland-ellis-pahiatua-mayor-new-years-honours-2017
Judicial complaints sandbagged
Note: to the persistent visitor from the Philippines [84 this year alone]. Today, 15 August 2016, you revealed your true purpose is to help cover Shonagh Kenderdine’s corruption and fraud. Like Hillary Clinton you left an electronic trail a mile wide.
http://www.surfgoo.com/results/?q=how+to+make+13+month+authorization+letter
LINK LINK
After the Philippine “visitor” is outed Google pointlessly prevents access to the stats page. How pathetic.
the-20th-commonwealth-law-conference-melbourne-2017
the-problem-faced-by-the-elliott-family plus photo 335 Greens Road
https://web.archive.org/web/20100524092854/http://chancerygreen.com/publications_archive.html
https://web.archive.org/details/http://www.chancerygreen.com:80/publications.html
https://web.archive.org/web/20100501000000*/chancerygreen.co.nz
https://web.archive.org/web/20130601000000*/chancerygreen.co.nz
https://web.archive.org/web/20140701000000*/chancerygreen.co.nz
https://web.archive.org/web/20150601000000*/chancerygreen.co.nz
https://web.archive.org/web/20160415000000*/chancerygreen.co.nz
http://www.stuff.co.nz/manawatu-standard/news/797643/Nine-turbine-sites-canned
Kenderdine lecture June 12 2012
img-424065323-0001
the-problem-faced-by-the-elliott-family plus photo – email redacted
turiteadocuments-website-blocked-in-new-zealand email redacted
Shelton just kept quiet about this
Manawatu wind cant meet peak demand
rmla_october_2006_newsletter
Letter – Mr Stichbury – 27 Oct 11
MinterEllisonRuddWatts and its spawn
1/ Karen Price 2002 – 2007
2/ Les Taylor 2002 – 2007 [Price’s lawyer at the LCRO – Legal Complaints Review Office]
3/ Sir David Gascoigne currently Consultant
Page saved here
They try to delete Gascoigne’s association with MinterEllisonRuddWatts as a consultant. [refresh the page to see it]
https://web.archive.org/web/20170718053235/https://minterellison.co.nz/people/sir-david-gascoigne
https://minterellison.co.nz/people/sir-david-gascoigne
Gascoigne was chairman and director of Transpower 2000 – 2007 and fully conversant with the secret wind farm plans.
Gascoigne was the independent reviewer, 2009-2013, 2015 of the Auditor-General’s audit allocation process. NB: when approached over the fraud the Auditor-General refused to cooperate.
NB Gascoigne who was Judicial Conduct Commissioner is married to Patsy Reddy the Governor General who just prior to taking office recommended expanding the GCSB’s powers to spy on all New Zealanders. Reddy also worked with Gascoigne at the law firm Watts and Patterson which became MinterEllisonRuddWatts in 2001.
Gascoigne with some of his badge collection
By Schwede66 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=56499762
MinterEllisonRuddWatts and its spawn
KEY COMPONENTS TO THE TURITEA WIND FARMCONTRACT
14385_Property_rights_as_human_rights_final_27_09_2_Edited_ExWS_KM
Parsing the RadioLive interview
Lawyer Annabell, gatekeeper for PNCC lies
Letter to the Editor of the Tribune
NZ_Wind_Energy_Conference_2012_Flyer_web
Revisit noise standards – academics
Found on palmerstonnorth.blogspot.com
MRP puts noise monitoring equipment for the Adam
Comment on the fourth wind farm proposed at Turitea
Excited crowds throng the official opening of the Turitea wind farm concentration camp
MANAWATU STANDARD EDITORIAL 2009
Ngahere Park and others speak out
Correspondence with the LCRO regarding the case against Karen Price
RESPONSE TO THE DECISION BY THE WELLINGTON STANDARDS COMMITTEE 3 (2)
Complaint to the New Zealand Law Society Karen Price (4)
Price submitted no defence at any time
Complaint to the New Zealand Law Society Karen Price
http://web.archive.org/web/20180120135310/https:/twitter.com/yumchar
To The Human Rights Commission
NOVEMBER 1 2017
To Hon David Parker Hon Andrew Little 1. 11. 2017
JANUARY 29 2018
Parker.Little reply to – Paul Stichbury
JANUARY 30 2018
To Minister of Justice; Attorney-General 30.1.2018
https://web.archive.org/web/20180407150142/https://www.pncc.govt.nz/yourcouncil/consultations/review-of-resource-consent-conditions-for-te-rere-hau-windfarm/ See Bill Hardings excellent correspondence – last pdf
New York political energy policies
This has been a multi-year fight. Motorimu was the first assault on our property. We found out that the company which went bankrupt was going to use secondhand turbines. I was told I would be grilled by the Motorimu lawyers as others were but this did not happen. They had no answer to my submission containing factual information about the global warming scam. Of course, Karen Price was a player at Motorimu. She was the one who let the cat out of the bag telling Helen Harker that worn out secondhand turbines would be used. She thought it was a joke. MRP went on to buy the consent and will expand Turitea into the area outside the fake consented Turitea footprint to the South.
Wind Farm impact assessment and project appraisal Jeff Baker Palmerston North
Bruce Rapley PhD latest book on the impact of infrasound from wind turbines
NB for security the contents of this and related websites are also found on two internet archives
The archived outclick
Non-wind farm related.
Turitea Fraud-supporting documentation. 
i have never such a well presented and documented record of official skullduggery. This sort of stuff could never be made up. The Govt. and their minions are not going to acknowledge the facts here because that is admitting the Turitea Decision is not worth the paper it is written on and errors in small matters mean errors in big things. the Turitea Board has failed the Govt., Mighty River Power and the public.
Pingback: The Turitea and Puketoi Wind Farms. A Case Study. | New Zealand wind farms - a public policy failure.
Pingback: TURITEA DOCUMENTS – UPDATED REGULARLY – A MUST TO VIEW – THE LATEST DEVELOPMENTS ARE BEYOND BELIEF. | Turitea Final Decision-supporting documentation.
Спасибо за информацию!!!!!